Lindsay vs. Hilary
Previous-
X17online.com | WireImage.com
Lindsay vs. Hilary
Lindsay Lohan and Hilary Duff: As different as they are now (and WOW are they), it's amazing to see how similarly they started out. That just makes it perfect to pit one against the other in a fight to the death ... well, or to pick which one is just all around better.
More Lindsay Lohan:
-
Walt Disney Pictures, ZUMA Press | Disney Channel
Round One
'Parent Trap' vs. 'Lizzie McGuire'
OK, we love 'Lizzie McGuire,' but 'The Parent Trap' has Lindsay Lohan playing twins, and actually makes us think she can act. Sorry, Hil.
Winner: LindsayMore Hilary Duff:
-
MGM | Disney
Round Two
'Agent Cody Banks' vs. 'Freaky Friday'
Here's another one where we think Hilary Duff is just adorable and we love her, but c'mon ... 'Freaky Friday' was where even critics noticed that Lindsay had real talent.
Winner: LindsayMore Lindsay Lohan:
-
Disney | 20th Century Fox
Round Three
'Confessions of a Drama Queen' vs.
'Cheaper by the Dozen'
Just ... yikes, Hilary. We're glad your career is on track now, but ... yikes.
Winner: LindsayMore Hilary Duff:
-
Paramount | Warner Bros
Round Four
'Mean Girls' vs. 'A Cinderella Story'
Yes, 'Mean Girls' is just too awesome for words, but Hilary Duff's 'Cinderella Story' is just so wholesome and cute, what can we do?
Winner: TieMore Lindsay Lohan:
-
Casablanca | Hollywood Records
Round Five
'Speak' vs. 'Metamorphosis'
Finally, we're back on the less evil side. While we can't even remember a song from Lindsay Lohan's debut album, we still love Hilary Duff's stuff ... we mean, 'Why Not?'
Winner: HilaryMore Hilary Duff:
-
Getty Images | WireImage.com
Round Six
Aaron Carter vs. Aaron Carter
Both girls dated Aaron Carter, and almost went to war over him. So how to pick a winner here? Look at the picture ... when Aaron dated Hilary Duff, he was young and still fun. When he dated Lindsay Lohan, he was older and sketchier.
Winner: HilaryMore Lindsay Lohan:
-
WireImage.com (2)
Round Seven
Joel Madden vs. Wilmer Valderama
Another set of boys ... and we're going with the opposite here. While Wilmer Vaderrama seems like a player, he's still a lot less hard core than Joel Madden. Nice one, Hilary, even if he turned out to be a tool.
Winner: HilaryMore Hilary Duff:
-
X17online.com | WireImage.com
The Decision
Lindsay vs. Hilary
Aww, Lindsay Lohan is ty-ty from our fight! That must be it. And look, Hilary Duff is still out giving her time to charities. While they might have tied in our competition, Hilary squeaks in the win at the last moment for just not being a huge disgusting trainwreck that's still spiraling down into the depths of patheticness. Congrats, Hilary!
Winner: HilaryMore Lindsay Lohan:
-
-
